Your child may repeatedly make mistakes with gerunds and infinitives, even after being shown a correction. For example, a student may write “She enjoys to read” when the intended standard form is “She enjoys reading”. Parents often worry that more worksheets are needed, but the first task is to find out whether the child understands the grammatical relationship and can apply it without a model.
Start with meaning rather than speed. Ask your child to compare “She enjoys reading” and “She wants to read”, explaining what changes and what stays the same. Then choose one authentic sentence from schoolwork and practise the relevant rule in a new context. This Punggol parent guide explains what to look for, how to teach the skill and when to ask the English teacher for feedback.
- Check the intended meaning before correcting the sentence.
- Identify one repeated error from authentic schoolwork.
- Teach the underlying language relationship with contrasting examples.
- Ask the child to explain the correction independently.
- Practise in a fresh paragraph after a few days.
- Use school feedback to decide whether further support is needed.
Understanding gerunds and infinitives in everyday English
A grammar pattern is easier to remember when the student can explain what it does. In gerunds and infinitives, the written form is a signal to the reader. If the signal is missing or incorrectly placed, the reader may misunderstand the sentence or need to reread it. The aim is accurate communication, not the mechanical use of a complicated rule.
Ask the child to explain the intended message of “She enjoys to read”. Then show “She enjoys reading” and ask which feature has changed. If the student can identify the difference in a short sentence but not in a composition, the problem may be transferring a familiar rule while managing several writing demands.
Worked examples parents can use
Example 1: discuss the meaning
They avoided making noise.
Invite the child to explain the grammatical choice in ordinary language. Then ask for a fresh sentence with a different person, place or event. Do not reward copying alone; the explanation shows whether the child understands the choice.
Example 2: discuss the meaning
We decided to leave early.
Invite the child to explain the grammatical choice in ordinary language. Then ask for a fresh sentence with a different person, place or event. Do not reward copying alone; the explanation shows whether the child understands the choice.
Example 3: discuss the meaning
He stopped talking to listen to the announcement.
Invite the child to explain the grammatical choice in ordinary language. Then ask for a fresh sentence with a different person, place or event. Do not reward copying alone; the explanation shows whether the child understands the choice.
A diagnostic checklist before more practice
- Ask the child to explain what the sentence means.
- Identify the word or punctuation that changes the meaning.
- Compare the corrected form with a different valid construction.
- Check whether the child can apply the rule without a model.
- Record whether a hint was needed.
A short diagnostic conversation is often more useful than a large worksheet. Record whether the child can answer each question without help, with a hint or only after a full explanation. This distinguishes a concept that has not been learned from a rule that is known but not consistently applied.
Why mistakes can return after correction
The child memorised the answer rather than the reason
Copying a corrected sentence can produce accurate work without changing understanding. Ask the student to explain the decision and then use it in a different context. This distinguishes recognition from independent control.
The rule was taught only in isolation
A short grammar exercise may present one type of example, while actual writing contains several demands. Move from one sentence to two, then to a short paragraph. Increase complexity only when the earlier stage is secure.
The child is concentrating on ideas
When writing a composition, students must generate ideas, organise them, choose words, spell and punctuate. A familiar grammar rule may be overlooked. A final editing pass focused on one recurring pattern can be more effective than trying to monitor everything at once.
The meaning has not been fully understood
For gerunds and infinitives, ask the student to explain the difference between “She enjoys to read” and “She enjoys reading”. If the explanation is unclear, return to a concrete example before attempting more difficult exercises. Understanding should come before speed.
How to teach the skill at home
First, make the meaning visible. Use familiar situations and one-sentence examples before moving to a paragraph. Let the child speak the sentence, explain the relevant relationship and then write it. When the child can do this independently, gradually increase the complexity.
Second, use contrast. Ask why one version better fits standard formal school English in the intended context. Finally, check transfer. A child who can explain a new example several days later has learned more than one who copies a corrected sentence repeatedly.
Practice by school level
Primary 1 to Primary 3
Use everyday situations, pictures, familiar objects and oral sentences. Children at this stage benefit from understanding the message before being asked to explain grammatical terminology. Introduce a small number of examples and invite them to create one of their own.
Primary 4 to Primary 6
Use short paragraphs, guided editing and examples from current schoolwork. Ask the child to locate the key structure and explain the meaning. For PSLE preparation, check the current SEAB requirements and the school’s guidance rather than treating old examination papers as a complete description of the present syllabus.
Secondary 1 to Secondary 4
Practise in explanations, functional writing, arguments and extended responses. The student should justify a grammatical choice and check whether it affects meaning or tone. For SEC preparation, refer to the current subject-level syllabus and the teacher’s expectations for G1, G2 or G3.
A four-week parent support plan
- Week 1 — Observe: collect several real examples and identify the recurring issue.
- Week 2 — Understand: practise meaning contrasts and explain the correct structure.
- Week 3 — Apply: use the target in short original writing, not just gap-filling.
- Week 4 — Transfer: edit an unseen paragraph and record the amount of help needed.
Look for progress from recognising the error with a hint, to explaining it independently, to using the correct form in new work. Do not promise a fixed number of weeks to mastery; children differ in prior knowledge and opportunities for practice.
When to ask the school for support
Bring two or three dated examples to the English teacher and ask whether the pattern is a narrow grammar gap or part of a wider difficulty with reading, vocabulary, sentence structure or written expression. Ask what the school has already taught and which practice would be most useful. Tuition is one possible form of additional teaching, but not a substitute for identifying the actual difficulty.
If language difficulties are broad, persistent and affect daily learning, discuss them with the school and seek qualified advice where appropriate. One type of grammar mistake is not evidence of a particular diagnosis.
Frequently asked questions
Should I correct every mistake in a composition?
Select a manageable target and let the child explain the correction. Correcting everything at once may obscure the central learning problem and discourage independent writing.
Does memorising rules help?
A rule can provide a useful reminder, but it should be connected to meaning and applied in new sentences. Memorisation alone does not show whether the child can use the language independently.
How can I tell whether my child has improved?
Give a fresh example after a gap. Ask for the child’s reasoning and note whether they can correct it without prompting. Independent transfer is a stronger sign of progress than copying a worked answer.
Further English guidance for Punggol parents
See our English grammar transfer guide, composition writing guide and synthesis and transformation guide. Use school feedback to choose the next learning target.

