A child may read each sentence correctly but lose the thread when a passage uses ‘this’, ‘those’, ‘they’, ‘such’ or ‘the former’. They may attach a pronoun to the nearest noun even when the meaning points to an earlier idea or a whole event. Parents often see the final mistake without knowing which part of the child’s reading or writing process broke down. More worksheets alone may repeat the same problem.
Reference words connect information across sentences and paragraphs. Readers must identify what each expression points to, check grammar and meaning, and sometimes recognise that ‘this’ refers to a complete situation rather than one noun. Start with a small example from recent schoolwork, ask the child to explain their reasoning, demonstrate one correction and then try the same skill on fresh material. The aim is independent understanding and confidence rather than memorising a model answer.
- Find the reference word.
- Look backwards for candidates.
- Check number and meaning.
- Test the substitution.
- Consider a whole-clause reference.
- Track contrasting pairs.
- Notice genuine ambiguity.
This guide supports families in Punggol, Sengkang and Singapore. Use the child’s current school syllabus, age and teacher feedback to decide the appropriate level of practice.
What is the learning problem?
A child may read each sentence correctly but lose the thread when a passage uses ‘this’, ‘those’, ‘they’, ‘such’ or ‘the former’. They may attach a pronoun to the nearest noun even when the meaning points to an earlier idea or a whole event. The child may know individual words or rules but struggle to apply them when several conditions or ideas appear together. Understanding the source of the error is more helpful than simply telling the child to concentrate.
What parents should teach first
Reference words connect information across sentences and paragraphs. Readers must identify what each expression points to, check grammar and meaning, and sometimes recognise that ‘this’ refers to a complete situation rather than one noun. A correction is useful only when the child can explain why it works and apply the principle to a different task.
Worked example to discuss
‘The volunteers cleaned the beach after the storm. This impressed the residents.’ Here ‘This’ most naturally refers to the volunteers’ action, not merely to the beach or the storm.
Ask which words carry the essential meaning, what relationship is being expressed and how the answer would change if a detail were different. This reveals whether the child understands the principle or merely recognises a familiar example.
1. Find the reference word
Circle the pronoun or demonstrative that is causing confusion.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
2. Look backwards for candidates
Read the preceding sentence or paragraph and identify possible nouns, events or ideas.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
3. Check number and meaning
A plural ‘they’ normally needs a plural referent, but grammar alone may not settle every ambiguity.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
4. Test the substitution
Replace the reference word with the proposed meaning and read the sentence again.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
5. Consider a whole-clause reference
‘This’ may point to an entire action or result rather than the nearest object.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
6. Track contrasting pairs
Expressions such as ‘the former’ and ‘the latter’ depend on the order of items previously named.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
7. Notice genuine ambiguity
If more than one referent fits, use broader context and acknowledge that the writing may be unclear.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
8. Apply the skill in writing
Ask the child to revise vague pronouns in their own paragraphs so readers know who or what is meant.
Practise this step with a short passage or the child’s own work. Ask for an explanation before giving feedback. If the child struggles, model one example, then let them attempt another with less prompting. A few focused examples can be more productive than a long correction session.
Common errors and what to avoid
Avoid calling every error carelessness, copying long model answers or correcting every minor detail at once. Identify the most important recurring problem. Make sure the child can explain the correction and use it in a new situation. Do not infer a diagnosis from one weak result.
A practical four-week plan
Week 1: Observe
Review two or three examples of the difficulty. Ask the child to explain what they thought the question or writing task required. Record the specific pattern.
Week 2: Practise with support
Use short examples that target one skill. Model one correction and ask the child to apply the reasoning to a different example.
Week 3: Apply independently
Choose an unfamiliar passage or writing prompt. Reduce adult prompts and ask the child to explain and check their own answer.
Week 4: Review and adjust
Compare new work with the original examples. Look for improved accuracy, clearer reasoning and greater independence. Ask the teacher what to prioritise next if needed.
Questions Punggol parents commonly ask
Does ‘this’ always refer to the previous noun?
No. It may refer to an event, statement or larger idea.
Should my child replace every pronoun with a noun?
No. Pronouns support cohesion when their references are clear.
How can parents practise this?
Choose short paragraphs, replace one reference word and explain why the substitution fits.
When should I ask the teacher for help?
If the difficulty continues across several tasks, share examples with the teacher and ask about suitable classroom or home support. One test result does not establish a broader learning condition.
Related guides and official information
- Understanding English instructions and questions
- Helping children organise composition writing
- MOE Primary English Language Syllabus
- SEAB official examination information
Prepared for parents in Punggol and Singapore. Confirm current assessment requirements with the school and relevant official syllabus. No examination outcome is guaranteed.

