Your child reads a passage fluently but becomes confused when a question asks what “it”, “they”, “this”, “those” or “such” refers to. The child may choose the nearest noun, even when the sentence is referring to an earlier idea or a group of things. Parents may wonder why the student can read every word but still misunderstand the passage.
Readers need to track references across sentences. Pronouns and other reference expressions help a writer avoid repeating the same nouns, but the reader must work out which person, object, event or idea is being referred to. This requires attention to grammar, number, meaning and the surrounding paragraph. Parents can teach children to trace the reference, test whether it fits and reread the sentence when more than one possibility seems reasonable.
- Circle the pronoun or reference word that is causing confusion.
- Look back for possible people, objects or ideas being referred to.
- Check whether the candidate matches singular or plural meaning and the sentence grammar.
- Replace the pronoun with the proposed noun or idea and reread the sentence.
- Use the surrounding paragraph when the reference points to an earlier event or whole idea.
- Ask the child to explain how the reference affects the meaning of the passage.
This guide helps parents identify a specific reading-comprehension difficulty that can be hidden when a child reads aloud smoothly.
1. Why a small word can affect the whole sentence
Words such as “it”, “they” and “this” are short, but they connect ideas. If the reader does not know what they refer to, the relationship between sentences may become unclear. The child may understand each individual word but misunderstand who acted, what changed or which idea is being discussed.
Some reference words point to a noun earlier in the same sentence. Others refer to something mentioned in a previous sentence or to a whole event or explanation. The reader must use context rather than select a word only because it is nearby.
2. Find possible references before choosing one
Ask the child to look back for the people, objects or ideas that could fit. If the pronoun is plural, a singular noun is unlikely to be the intended reference. If the sentence describes an action, consider which candidate could logically perform it.
Grammar and meaning work together. A candidate may match the number but make no sense in the passage. The child should use both the structure of the sentence and the content of the paragraph.
3. Replace the pronoun and read again
A simple checking method is to insert the possible reference in place of the pronoun. Does the sentence still make sense? Does it preserve the writer’s meaning? If the replacement makes the sentence confusing or illogical, the candidate may be wrong.
This substitution is a checking tool, not a rule that always identifies the answer immediately. Some sentences require the reader to consider the wider passage or a whole idea rather than one noun.
4. Understand reference to an earlier idea
Words such as “this”, “that” or “such” may refer to an entire event, argument or situation. A child may look only for the nearest noun and miss that the writer is referring to a previous statement or action.
Ask what happened in the previous sentence and whether the reference could summarise that event. The child can restate the sentence with a short phrase such as “this decision” or “that change” to make the connection clearer, provided the phrase accurately reflects the text.
5. Notice when several candidates are possible
Sometimes a passage contains more than one possible noun. In such cases, the child needs to examine the grammar, meaning and wider context. Reread the preceding sentences and ask which candidate produces the most coherent interpretation.
Do not force a quick answer when the text is genuinely ambiguous. For school comprehension, use the most defensible reference supported by the passage and follow the teacher’s explanation where a question has a specific expected answer.
6. Practise with short passages first
Choose a short paragraph with a few clear pronouns. Ask the child to draw a small arrow from each reference word to the person or idea it refers to. Then remove the arrows and explain the paragraph again.
Once this is secure, use longer passages where the reference may cross sentence boundaries. Avoid turning every reading session into a grammar worksheet. The purpose is to support meaning, not interrupt reading constantly.
7. Link reference tracking to comprehension questions
A question may ask what a pronoun refers to directly, but reference tracking also affects inference, sequencing and understanding cause and effect. If the child misunderstands who “they” refers to, the answer may describe the wrong person’s action.
When reviewing a wrong answer, identify whether the child misunderstood the vocabulary, the reference or the wider idea. These are different problems and need different forms of practice.
8. Support by school stage
Primary 1 to Primary 3
Use short sentences and familiar people or objects. Ask the child who “he”, “she”, “they” or “it” refers to, using pictures or simple stories where helpful.
Primary 4 to Primary 6
Practise tracking references across a few sentences and replacing pronouns with the correct noun or idea. Include this skill in comprehension discussion rather than testing it only in isolation.
Secondary 1 to Secondary 2
Students should track references across paragraphs, including words that summarise an earlier event or argument. Ask them to justify their choice using grammar and context.
Secondary 3 to Secondary 4
Older students should interpret reference in more complex texts and distinguish between a reference to a noun, a situation or an entire proposition. They should explain how the reference shapes the argument or passage meaning.
9. A reference-tracking routine
- Circle the pronoun or reference expression.
- Look back for possible people, objects or ideas.
- Check grammar, number and meaning.
- Substitute the candidate and reread the sentence.
- Use the wider paragraph if the reference is to an event or idea.
- Explain the connection in one clear sentence.
Questions parents commonly ask
Should my child draw arrows to every pronoun?
Not for every passage. Use arrows as a teaching aid when the child loses track of references. As the skill improves, the child should be able to follow the links mentally.
What if the nearest noun seems to fit?
Check the whole sentence and paragraph. The nearest noun is not automatically the correct reference. Grammar and meaning should both support the choice.
Is this a grammar problem or a comprehension problem?
It can involve both. The child needs grammatical awareness to identify possible references and reading comprehension to understand the passage’s meaning.
What if the pronoun refers to a whole sentence?
Ask what event, decision or idea the previous sentence describes. The reference may summarise more than one noun, so look at the wider meaning.
Help your child follow the links between sentences
Reading comprehension depends on more than recognising vocabulary. Children also need to track the people, objects and ideas that reference words point to. Teach them to look back, check grammar and meaning, substitute the candidate and reread the paragraph. This makes the connections in a passage clearer.
For related guidance, read Why Does My Child Read Every Paragraph but Miss How the Ideas Connect? and Why Does My Child Memorise Vocabulary but Not Recognise the Word in a Reading Passage?.
Prepared for parents in Punggol and Sengkang. Educational guidance only; follow the child’s English syllabus and teacher guidance.

