When a Humanities question asks students to compare two sources, many children write one paragraph about Source A and another about Source B. They may describe both accurately but never explain how the sources are similar or different. A comparison requires a direct relationship between the material, supported by evidence from each source.
Parents can help by teaching the child to identify the exact issue being compared, state the relationship between the sources and use a detail from each to support that comparison. The student should compare what the sources say or show, not simply their appearance, length or format unless those features are relevant to the task.
- Read the question to identify the focus of the comparison.
- Identify the main claim, viewpoint or message in each source.
- State a clear similarity or difference before giving supporting details.
- Use relevant evidence from both sources in the same comparison.
- Check whether the sources agree on one aspect but differ on another.
- Avoid treating different wording as proof of different viewpoints when the meaning is similar.
What comparison actually means
A comparison explains a relationship. Two sources may agree that a policy changed daily life but disagree about whether the change was beneficial. They may share a concern while offering different reasons. They may also discuss different aspects of the same issue, in which case the student needs to be precise about the limited basis for comparison.
The child should first understand each source separately, then bring them together. If they do not know what each source is saying, a comparison will become guesswork.
A four-step source comparison routine
1. Identify the issue
Underline or restate the subject of the comparison. Is the question asking about a policy, an event, a problem, a response or a person’s viewpoint? Keep the comparison focused on that issue.
2. Summarise each source accurately
In a few words, state the relevant message or viewpoint of Source A and Source B. Do not copy a full paragraph. The summaries should represent the parts that relate to the question.
3. State the relationship directly
Explain whether the sources agree, disagree or offer different emphasis. A sentence such as ‘Both sources suggest that the policy affected employment, but they disagree about whether the impact was beneficial’ gives the reader a clear comparison.
4. Support the comparison with evidence
Use a detail from each source and explain how the details show the similarity or difference. Evidence from only one source cannot fully support a comparison between two sources.
Why students accidentally write two summaries
Summarising feels safer because it allows the child to describe what is visible. Comparison requires an additional decision: what relationship exists between the two messages? Students may also be afraid of misinterpreting a source, so they avoid stating whether there is agreement or disagreement.
Practise stating the relationship first in plain language. Then return to the source details to check whether the comparison is fair. If the evidence does not support the first interpretation, revise the comparison.
Not every difference is a disagreement
Two sources may focus on different aspects of an issue without contradicting each other. One may discuss the economic effect of a change while another discusses its social effect. These sources are different in focus, but they may not disagree about the same claim.
Teach the child to compare like with like. Ask whether both sources address the same point. If not, explain the difference in emphasis rather than forcing a disagreement.
How parents can practise at home
Choose two short articles, notices or historical extracts about the same topic. Ask the child to write one sentence explaining what each source says. Then ask for one similarity and one difference, each supported by a detail from both sources. Keep the exercise brief and discuss why the evidence supports the comparison.
For younger learners, compare two advertisements or descriptions of the same event. For secondary students, use suitable Humanities source materials and teacher-provided practice questions. The complexity should match the student’s current syllabus and instruction.
Common comparison mistakes
Writing Source A and Source B separately. Bring the two messages together in the same point of comparison.
Using evidence from only one source. A comparison needs support from both sources.
Confusing different wording with different meaning. Restate each message in plain language before judging.
Claiming disagreement when the sources discuss different aspects. Compare the same issue and acknowledge differences in emphasis.
Quoting without explaining. Tell the reader how the detail proves similarity or difference.
How to respond when the sources are complicated
If a source has several claims, select only the part that answers the question. A source may agree with another source on one point and differ on another. Students should not force an all-or-nothing judgement. A balanced comparison can acknowledge mixed relationships when the evidence supports them.
When to ask for help
If the child can summarise sources but cannot compare them, ask the teacher whether the issue is interpretation, evidence selection or written explanation. Practise the missing stage. If the student does not understand the source language or context, address that first rather than demanding a polished comparison.
How this connects to exam craft
Comparing sources involves reading accurately, identifying relationships, selecting evidence and communicating a reasoned judgement. These are core exam-craft behaviours. For the wider framework, see What Is Exam Craft? How Does a Child Turn Learning into Marks?.
The aim is to help students move beyond two separate descriptions and explain clearly how the evidence relates.

