A child may say, “That is not fair,” when a sibling gets more screen time, a classmate receives a different role or a teacher applies a rule. The feeling may be genuine, but the statement alone does not explain what is unfair or what should change. Critical thinking helps children move from an immediate reaction to a clearer judgement: what rule or expectation applies, who is affected and what evidence supports the concern.
For parents in Punggol, these everyday moments can become useful lessons in reasoning without dismissing a child’s feelings. Fairness is not always identical treatment. Different people may have different needs or responsibilities, and a fair decision should be explained. This guide shows how to help children identify the issue, consider another perspective and express a concern constructively.
- Acknowledge the feeling before analysing the claim.
- Ask what the child means by fair in this particular situation.
- Identify the rule, expectation or criterion being applied.
- Consider who is affected and whether relevant circumstances differ.
- Help the child propose a reasonable response and explain why.
Scope: this guide is about everyday reasoning and communication. Where a child reports bullying, discrimination, unsafe behaviour or serious mistreatment, listen carefully and take appropriate adult action rather than treating it as a debate exercise.
Why “not fair” needs a clearer explanation
The word fair can mean equal treatment, equal opportunity, following an agreed rule, meeting different needs or sharing responsibilities appropriately. These ideas can overlap, but they are not identical. Giving every child exactly the same amount of help may not be fair if one child needs additional support to complete the same task.
The child therefore needs to identify the fairness criterion. Are they saying that a rule was broken, that someone was treated differently without a good reason, that they were not given a chance or that the outcome disappointed them? Each concern needs a different response.
Teach a four-part fairness explanation
- Situation: What exactly happened? Describe what was seen or heard without adding an assumption about motives.
- Criterion: What would fair treatment mean here—same rule, equal opportunity, appropriate support or shared responsibility?
- Evidence: Which detail shows that the criterion was or was not followed?
- Proposal: What change or explanation would make the situation more reasonable?
An example at home
Suppose one child is allowed to stay up later because they are older. A younger child says, “That is not fair because you like them more.” The parent can acknowledge the disappointment and explain the relevant reason: bedtime may differ because of age, school schedule or individual needs. The child can still ask for clarity, but the claim of favouritism needs evidence.
This example shows that equal treatment is not always identical treatment. Parents should explain the principle behind a difference instead of relying only on “because I said so.” A clear explanation helps children understand the rule even when they dislike the outcome.
An example at school
A student may feel that group work is unfair because one teammate does less work but receives the same mark. Help the child identify what is known: which tasks were assigned, what each person completed and how the teacher assessed the work. Avoid assuming that the teacher knows nothing or that the teammate deliberately avoided work. Encourage the child to raise the concern respectfully with specific examples.
How perspective-taking improves fairness reasoning
Ask the child how another person might describe the same situation. The other person may have different information, responsibilities or needs. Understanding that perspective does not automatically make it correct; it helps the child evaluate the situation more fully. The child should then return to the evidence and the agreed criteria.
Questions parents can ask
- “What part of this situation feels unfair to you?”
- “What rule or expectation do you think should apply?”
- “Were the people in the same circumstances?”
- “What evidence would help us understand what happened?”
- “What change would be fair, and why?”
How to help a child express disagreement
Model a calm sentence: “I felt this was unfair because I thought the same rule applied to everyone. Can you explain why the arrangements were different?” This identifies the concern and asks for an explanation without accusing the other person of bad intentions.
If the child is upset, deal with the emotion first. Reasoning is difficult when a child is overwhelmed. Return to the discussion later, when they can describe the facts and consider alternatives.
What parents should avoid
- Do not dismiss every complaint as jealousy or attention-seeking.
- Do not assume that identical treatment is always the fairest outcome.
- Do not insist that children agree with an adult’s decision without understanding the reason.
- Do not ask a child to tolerate bullying or discrimination in the name of seeing both sides.
- Do not turn a genuine concern into an abstract debate before listening to what happened.
How this connects to Character and Citizenship Education
Singapore’s Primary Character and Citizenship Education syllabus includes responsible decision-making, perspective-taking, consideration of consequences and respectful relationships. Those outcomes are relevant to everyday fairness discussions: children learn to consider the needs of others while taking responsibility for their own words and actions. See the MOE Primary CCE Syllabus.
What progress looks like
The child increasingly explains what seems unfair, identifies the relevant rule or criterion and supports the concern with specific details. They can listen to another explanation, revise an assumption and suggest a reasonable next step. Their feelings still matter; they are simply learning to communicate them more clearly.
For understanding another person’s viewpoint, read How Can My Child Understand Another Person’s Point of View Without Having to Agree?. For balanced decision-making, see How Can I Help My Child Make Better Decisions?.
Related parent guides in this critical-thinking series: How Can I Teach My Child the Difference Between Fact, Opinion and Inference?; What Is an Assumption, and How Can I Teach My Child to Notice One?; How Can My Child Tell the Difference Between a Strong Argument and a Weak One?.

